Frogg Toggs: A broken promise of waterproof clothing?

Wet Vest
Here’s a shot of me wearing the down vest I wore under my Frogg Toggs just after coming in from my walk in the rain. The dark areas are wet. My Frogg Toggs didn’t keep me dry.

I already had a Precip jacket from Marmot with their proprietary waterproofing material and some pants with a GoreTex lining, both of which offer protection from rain, but I wanted to reserve those for hiking and use something else while riding my motorcycle. Enter Frogg Toggs. I hadn’t heard of them before, but when I was in a sporting goods shop somewhere the salesman tried to interest me in them. I wasn’t sold. I thought the material had a strange feel and the fit seemed awkward. Some days or weeks later, when I was in a motorcycle shop in Montrose, Colorado when they turned up again, and I read the promotional materials promising waterproof clothing, I took the Frogg Toggs plunge.

I bought a matching jacket and pants set, for about $90 if I recall the price correctly: style FT10322-27. I got a bit of a discount because there was a small stain on the jacket. One day I decided to give my Frogg Toggs clothing a trial run by going for a walk in the rain. When I returned in a half hour or so and took off the Frogg Toggs my clothing underneath was dry in places but wet in others. I was disappointed by what I considered a rather lackluster showing by the Frogg Toggs gear.

I contacted Frogg Toggs and they assured me their clothing is indeed waterproof and agreed to exchange my suit, assumed defective, for another like it.

After receiving the new suit I performed the same, real-world test of going for a walk in the rain. The results were the same. My clothing under the Frogg Toggs was dry in places and wet in others. This time I photographed my clothing and sent copies of the photos to Frogg Toggs. I’m including those photos with this report.

Here's a shot of the back of the down vest I wore under my Frogg Toggs just after coming in from my walk in the rain. The dark areas are wet. My Frogg Toggs didn't keep me dry.
Here’s a shot of the back of the down vest I wore under my Frogg Toggs just after coming in from my walk in the rain. The dark areas are wet. My Frogg Toggs didn’t keep me dry.

Here is what I wrote to Frogg Toggs along with the photos: “Today I wore the replacement FroggToggs you sent me for the first time. I went for a walk in the rain. The rain was moderate. I walked for 2 miles, about 49 minutes. When I returned my clothing underneath was very wet in many places. See the attached photos of the vest I wore beneath the FroggToggs. My pants were also wet.

Having now had two sets of these clothes, neither of which have kept me anywhere near dry, how am I supposed to believe the claims made by FroggToggs that your garments are waterproof?”

The next day I heard back from Frogg Toggs. Here is a copy of the email I received:
“Hey Russ,

I’m very sorry you are having issues out of your product, I can replace that suit for you no problem.”

I replied with this:
“At this point I really don’t believe that FroggToggs are waterproof as advertised. I don’t see any point in having you send me suit after suit after suit only to find out that each one leaks. If you want to have somebody wear a suit in the rain for 30 minutes to make sure it doesn’t leak and send that one to me fine, but I don’t want to play the game of mailing things back-and-forth for the rest of my life. It’s not worth it. My blog review will state my honest experience with your products and recommend strongly against purchasing them, unless of course you can convince me somehow that you actually make a waterproof suit.”

The response I received was this:
“Like I said I am sorry if there are anything else I can do for you please let me know.”

So, I’ve had two sets of Frogg Toggs, neither of which have kept me anywhere near dry. Were they both defective, from the same batch of defective materials perhaps? Are Frogg Toggs, any Frogg Toggs really waterproof? Does the company play the game of replacing garment after garment until consumers just give up as did I? All I know is that I had two supposedly waterproof suits neither of which were anywhere near waterproof and that I cannot endorse or recommend Frogg Toggs as a result. The only recommendation I can make under the circumstances which is based on my personal experience as described above would be to avoid so-called waterproof clothing from Frogg Toggs: DON’T BUY

This blog takes an enormous amount of time and energy to build and maintain . If you have found something useful or entertaining please Favorite (bookmark) this link and use it when you shop at Amazon. Doing so will cost you no more and in some cases I may receive a small commission. Your support in the form of using my link or making a PayPal Donation will be greatly appreciated. Thank you.

24 thoughts on “Frogg Toggs: A broken promise of waterproof clothing?”

  1. Unfortunately some companies don’t take their mission seriously but still make money selling defective products! What a shame! I like hiking in the rain and usually use my K- Way poncho that I discovered years ago on a mountain hiking trip and have bought two more in case some one in our group doesn’t have rain gear. It has a hood and covers you from shoulders to ankles and has room for a backpack underneath. I love it- not sure it would be comfortable riding Pee- wee though! It looks as if the rain came in through the seams judging from your photos!

    1. You’re welcome.

      You might want to poke around a bit and look at specific Frogg Togg products and other reviews you might be able to find. I’ve seen reviews other than my own that were positive.

    1. The idea of breathable, waterproof clothing is to keep you dry. Is it not? If it fails to do either one of those it fails in its mission. Cotton breathes too, but it won’t keep you dry. Neither did my Frogg Toggs. They failed.

  2. I had a set and wore to a sporting event and the front of my body from shoulders to knees was soaked. Anything that wasn’t getting rained on, my back and butt due to sitting was dry. Really disappointed especially emailing them and gettin NO response!

  3. I’ve also used frogs tongs and my clothes underneath were also wet. The water soaked right through. Going into the trash. Waste of money.

  4. I was given a big sales pitch on my frogg togg motorcycle rain gear . I wore it on a cycle ride in the rain , I was soaked from one end to the other , every buddy was laughing, when I took my coat off , butt me .

  5. I really wish I had seen this before. I just got back from a 20 minute motorbike ride in my brand new Frogg Toggs. After changing out of my soaked shirt and pants, I’ve spent the last 30 minutes trying to figure out how to get my money back.

  6. I bought a Frogg Toggs two-piece rain suit at Academy Sports back in 2006 as they were SO HIGHLY recommended. Especially because they allegedly so-called breathed. What a crock! I’d have been less wet NOT wearing it! For years I thought I was alone. So glad I stumbled onto this blog! I’LL NOT EVER BUY THAT CRAP AGAIN! WHAT A RIP OFF!

    1. Well, they may breathe, but in my experience they also leak.

      Since my motorcycling days are behind me I’m no longer following the gear & what’s going on by way of waterproof clothing. I also expect there are alternatives, but I expect they cost more that Frogg Toggs. Sometimes you get what you pay for.

      Thanks for your comments.

  7. I have warn mine in the rain riding my motorcycle …Never got wet….ditto breaking camp and packing up walking to the car …In and out at the gas pumps….Always worked great for me!

    1. I have heard the same from at least one other. I’m glad they work for you. I have also heard from numerous people stories more like my own, such as those found within the other comments here.

  8. I wear mine working trails in high mountains where rains can drench you in a few minutes. My Frogg Toggs have performed perfectly.

  9. Yep these are USELESS for rain gear. I wanted them for my Kayak because they are light weight. After a heavy rain I was soaked to the bone. Buy real rain gear.

    1. There are people that say they love Frogg Toggs and people that say as you and I have, that theirs were ineffective at keeping them dry. I would encourage people considering a purchase to make sure they can easily get a refund if not satisfied and to carefully test their purchase ASAP.

  10. Same here… bought them (jacket and coat, black , 100% polypropylene, before my motorcycle. Tried them 1 year later when I bought my bike to find out that … well it’s better than nothing but it doesnt keeps me from getting wet 😦

What do you think? Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

RVing America

Pizza Box Books

Now delivering to classrooms everywhere!

Live Laugh RV

Our Next Chapter

%d bloggers like this: